PQ Crypta Logo

ACK Frequency extension offered

Negotiate the extension, or ignore it. Either is correct; failing is not.

Jump to an anomaly59

Every one of these is a page: what the server emits, the clause it is judged against, and how each client answered. The full list carries the verdict tallies too.

q-ack-frequency · draft-ietf-quic-ack-frequency · discretionary · layer quic · udp/4467 · MAY

Passing this means: The RFC permits either behaviour; the report says which was chosen.

Anomaly type: transport

How each client answered

ClientVersionVerdictWhat happened
curl libcurl/8.23.0 ngtcp2/1.26.0 Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
quinn noq fork (2d81eb2) Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
aioquic 1.7.2 (PyPI wheel) Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
chromium build 1254 Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
quic-go quic-go v0.65.0 (h1:RAro2j2yN9a9) Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
quiche 0.30.0 (d7387df) Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
neqo 0.34.0 (7279e4b) Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
picoquic 3a0c3bc Pass Handled it: negotiated the extension and sent 1 ACK_FREQUENCY frames.
ngtcp2 e82176c Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
lsquic 4.11.1 (cd23e52) Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
xquic 8099bd2 + demo_client IPv6 fix Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
msquic 2.7.0 (d3d28f7) Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.
quico 0.8.0 (npm) Pass Handled it: ignored the extension, which the specification permits.

What the clause requires

Negotiate the extension, or ignore it. Either is correct; failing is not.

Judged against draft-ietf-quic-ack-frequency.

Run this one yourself

Every test is reachable from your own client. Nothing here needs an account.

curl -s https://conformance.pqcrypta.com/catalog.json \
  | jq '.tests[] | select(.id == "q-ack-frequency")'

⟨ QUANTUM ERROR PORTAL ⟩

Navigate the Error Dimensions